The MHK who challenged the health minister's conduct in Tynwald and the House of Keys says a report into the affair vindicates her concern.
Serious shortcomings in the way senior management at the Department of Health advised David Anderson have emerged in the report by Tywnald's standards committee.
It concludes the minister inadvertently misled the House in statements he made about a letter from consultants expressing serious concerns about patient safety at Noble's Hospital.
And the report says opportunities to set the matter straight were badly mishandled by the department's chief executive, David Killip.
South Douglas member Kate Beecroft challenged Mr Anderson's position at the time.
She remains unhappy at his handling of the entire situation:
Clip 1
'Unprecedented' situation after deemster in Island's first group litigation case resigns
Immigration changes designed to stop exploitation by 'bad eggs'
Plantation wood, telegraph poles and Satnav to be discussed in the House of Keys
Contingency budget for horse tram tracks 'significantly increased'
MHK to seek re-election in Arbory, Castletown and Malew