On Air Now Mannin Line Noon - 1:00pm
Now Playing

Doctors say assessment of Manx Care exposes "severe systemic, operational, and governance failures"

Picture credit: Manx Radio

Isle of Man Medical Society responds to DHSC report

A group representing the Island's doctors has responded to a government assessment of Manx Care, saying the report rightly acknowledges the tireless commitment of frontline staff.

However, the Isle of Man Medical Society says it also exposes severe systemic, operational, and governance failures.

The Department of Health and Social Care's assessment of Manx Care found a mixed performance during 2025/26, with long waiting times and a £14.9 million operational deficit.

You can read more on that HERE. Manx Care told it must make 'considerable further improvement' - Manx Radio

The Medical Society says the assessment confirms what its members and the Noble’s Hospital Medical Staff Committee have warned of for several years.

It says: "Clinical services are being destabilised by inadequate inpatient bed capacity, bureaucratic delays, fragmented infrastructure, and a failure to meaningfully empower frontline medical leadership."

The DHSC's assessment found cancer waiting time standards remained below target, diagnostic waiting times increased and access to GP appointments remained challenging in parts of the Island.

In its response, the Society says it is 'deeply concerned by the deterioration in timely access to secondary care and diagnostics, which places patients at tangible risk of clinical harm while they wait'.

The assessment also painted a negative picture of the Noble's Hospital Emergency Department, where performance also worsened. 

In 2025/26, 63.7% of patients were admitted, transferred or discharged within four hours of arrival, compared with 66.5% the previous year and a target of 78%. 

The availability and number of inpatient beds has been a sore spot for the Society and the Medical Staff Committee for years.

The Society says the assessment vindicates the Medical Staff Committee's pleas by confirming that adult general and acute bed occupancy rose to 87.8% (from 84.5%) even after delayed transfers of care were more than halved (from 194 to 81), prolonged hospital stays (>21 days) fell from 677 to 516, and >7-day stays fell from 2,282 to 1,892. 

"This proves beyond doubt", it says, "that Noble’s Hospital suffers from a fundamental structural shortage of inpatient beds - not merely a discharge bottleneck - resulting in chronic exit block, 12-hour trolley waits, ambulance handover delays, medical outliers occupying surgical beds, and cancelled elective operations."

Missing from the DHSC's assessment of workforce resilience, the Society says, is 'any candid reckoning with the British Medical Association’s Culture of Care Barometer survey published in February 2026'. 

It says: "That survey laid bare a profound disconnect between executive leadership and the medical workforce, revealing that fewer than a quarter of doctors at Manx Care would recommend it as a place to work and highlighting widespread concern over the lack of strong, visible senior leadership. 

"While peer-to peer collegiality among frontline doctors remains a vital strength, relying on goodwill to paper over systemic governance cracks is unsustainable; without addressing the cultural and leadership deficits identified by doctors themselves, the Island will continue to struggle with substantive medical recruitment and retention."

The Society has published its own list of recommendations for medium and long-term reform.

It's calling for an expansion of inpatient bed capacity, an end to what it calls costly external private contracts and for focus to be on harnessing 'internal clinical expertise'.

In the longer term, it wants an overhauling of 'top-heavy management', for administrative expenditure to be capped, and for wider reform of Manx Care's Board governance.

Meeting requested

A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson told Manx Radio: “The Department received the Isle of Man Medical Society’s assessment on Wednesday and contacted the Society on Thursday to request a constructive meeting.

“We believe it is important that Manx Care is given the opportunity to respond to the concerns raised and outline the significant work already under way, including improvements that have been implemented and further developments that are approaching delivery.

“We welcome constructive engagement with healthcare professionals and believe that open dialogue, mutual respect and a shared understanding of the progress being made are essential to improving services for patients and service users.”

More from Isle of Man News