Legislative Council edges closer to decision on Bishop's voting powers

The Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 now moves to its final stage

The Legislative Council has taken another step towards deciding whether the Bishop of Sodor and Man should retain voting rights in Tynwald sittings.

Members have now completed the clauses stage of the Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 which, if approved, would remove the Bishop’s ability to vote in both Tynwald and LegCo, leaving the position as an advisory role only.

An amendment from MLC Gary Clueit, which sought to allow the current Bishop to keep her vote until the end of her tenure, was defeated.

Mr Clueit argued it would be reasonable for the Bishop to complete her term under the same conditions she accepted the role, rather than introducing such a significant change midway through.

However, he has since indicated his intention to bring the amendment back when the Bill reaches its final stage next week.

To succeed, it would require a two-thirds majority rather than a simple majority.

If Mr Clueit’s amendment were to pass, the Bill would return to the House of Keys for further consideration.

If it fails, and the Bill is passed in its current form, the Bishop’s vote would be removed entirely - marking a significant constitutional change for the Isle of Man.

The Bishop herself is opposed to any delay to the change, expressing the view that if it is to happen, it should happen without postponement.

Once the Legislative Council completes its final consideration, the Bill will proceed to Royal Assent.