Peel Commissioners were divided last night as they discussed the new sewage treatment plant in the Sunset City.
Despite widespread public opposition, board members were evenly split about whether to support the scheme, which would see an open works built near the power station.
Both sides put their views forward at the meeting but, in the end, the debate required the casting vote of the chairman, Rodger Gimbert, who voted against.
He explained how the voting went:
Patients 'strongly satisfied' with virtual GP pilot
Service to be evaluated before decision on whether to expand to other practices
Island to mark the golden anniversary of the Millennium of Tynwald
Tynwald Ceremony Arrangements Committee to oversee the organisation
Douglas Council looking for residents views on the future of Noble's Park
Local authority wants to know what could be improved in the area
Tynwald backs major overhaul of Isle of Man planning system
A more efficient, user-friendly process is promised
Laxey Christmas Market returns
More than 100 vendors expected there this weekend