Teaching union wants urgent meeting with minister over 'toxic and broken' relationship

Senior NAHT figure says he will not stand by and see school leaders 'forced out and left crushed'

A senior figure at one of the unions that represents teachers on the Island says he's written to the education minister in a bid to avoid a dispute.

Assistant General Secretary at the National Association of Head Teachers Rob Kelsall wants an urgent meeting with Daphne Caine and her department's chief officer.

It's after he described the relationship between schools and civil servants on the Island as "toxic and broken", adding "we will not stand by and see school leaders forced out of their jobs and left crushed".

In response, the Department of Education, Sport and Culture has issued the following statement:

"The Department is aware of the letter issued by the National Association of Head Teachers (NAHT) and acknowledges the serious nature of the concerns raised.

In relation to the allegations – including suggestions of a toxic culture and abuse of policies – the Department completely refutes these claims.

They do not reflect the standards or values we uphold within DESC.

We believe the concerns stem from a matter that has been under discussion for some time and remains subject to ongoing internal processes.

While we recognise the impact on those involved, it would be inappropriate to comment further to ensure due process, fairness, and confidentiality.

DESC remains committed to working constructively with all recognised teaching unions and professional associations.

We continue to engage on key matters including pay, working conditions, and professional support for educators.

A respectful and collaborative relationship with all education partners – including school leaders and their representatives – is essential to delivering the best outcomes for learners across the Isle of Man.

We remain open to meaningful dialogue to support that goal."