DEFA deemed euthanasia the 'only option' after legal proceedings
An American XL Bully-type dog has been put to sleep after being illegally imported to the Isle of Man last year.
Following court proceedings, Charlie's owner admitted he'd been illegally imported after the ban.
The decision was made in line with the law that was approved by Tynwald in 2023 which banned the breed's importation to the Island.
It followed the UK's introduction of a licensing system and a ban on breeding and rehoming them in the hope of stopping the Isle of Man from becoming a XL Bully 'sanctuary'.
After seizing Charlie under the Customs and Excise Management Act 1986, he was then forfeited to the Department of Environment, Food and Agriculture.
Recognising the 'heartbreak' of the outcome and following 'extensive consideration', DEFA determined euthanasia was the only option that upheld the law and its intent, and avoided anything that could undermine its deterrent effect.
Government says it was 'deeply regrettable' and the decision was not taken lightly, but says it serves as a stark reminder of the consequences of bringing banned dogs to the Isle of Man.
Alongside XL Bully-type dogs, the following breeds or types remain subject to a strict import ban here:
- Pit Bull Terrier type
- Japanese Tosa
- Dogo Argentino
- Fila Brasileiro
Prospective owners of any bully-type dog, particularly puppies, are now being urged to exercise extreme caution and to check the online guidance before importing or purchasing a dog in the UK.
Some dogs sold under other breed names in the UK may grow to meet the criteria of an XL Bully-type as typing of XL Bullies can only be confirmed once they're fully grown.
If such dogs are later identified as banned types, they may be subject to similar enforcement action.
The ManxSPCA has also commented on the ruling, calling it 'a tragic loss' and 'a vital lesson'.
In a statement posted on social media, the charity says it's 'deeply saddened' after Charlie came into its care in November last year.
Throughout his time there, the team say he showed a 'gentle and loving nature' despite the uncertainty of his future.
The ManxSPCA says it made formal representations to DEFA in the hope of saving him, as it says one of its core principles is to never put a healthy animal to sleep.
However, in this case, it says the matter was taken out of the charity's hands.
"While we understand that the law must be upheld, we believe it is vital to acknowledge the tragedy at the heart of this situation: that a dog paid the ultimate price for human error." - ManxSPCA
The ManxSPCA says it's 'regrettable' that the current legal framework doesn't provide a path to allow American XL Bully-type dogs to remain on the Island 'safely and lawfully'.
It says Charlie's story must now serve as a warning to all potential dog owners and is urging prospective owners to adopt responsibly.
Manx Utilities spends £3.1m on consultants for Cair Vie wind farm project
Animal campaigner saddened by loss of XL Bully
No evidence of corruption found at Ramsey Commissioners
Maintenance works to interrupt electricity supplies on Friday
Jurby landowner calls for bus shelter relocation amid ongoing concerns