The five year Tax Cap has not worked according to Douglas West MHK.
The initiative introduced in February was designed to attract wealthy people to the Island.
Chris Thomas claims the number of individuals paying the tax cap amount of £120,000 has fallen by one sixth in the last year.
There are currently 58 people who have elected for the cap, and only one of those moved to the Island this tax year.
Mr Thomas says the shortfall of contributors means most of the income tax is being supported by general tax payers:
Clip 1
Tynwald's Auditor General publishes annual report
Public warned of increased risk of wildfires
Cocaine, ketamine and cannabis dealer jailed
Assisted Dying Bill mover pleased as Jersey becomes first place in British Isles to legalise assisted deaths