Tynwald Committee hears from Jersey politician on Budget transparency and reform

Isle of Man’s budget process under scrutiny as Jersey highlights public consultation model

A Tynwald Select Committee examining the role of the legislature in the Isle of Man's Budget process has taken evidence from Jersey parliamentarian Inna Gardiner, Chair of the States of Jersey Public Accounts Committee.

Appearing virtually, Deputy Gardiner outlined how Jersey’s Budget is released publicly 12 weeks ahead of debate in the States Assembly - significantly earlier than on the Isle of Man, where the Budget is only made public on the day it is presented in Tynwald.

She told the committee that Jersey’s extended timeline allows meaningful scrutiny to begin immediately, including public engagement events and review by elected members.

She added that the system is designed to foster transparency and accountability, even when tax changes are proposed.

“In Jersey, if the government proposes a tax increase, that would be part of the Budget proposition and the public would know 12 weeks in advance,” she said.

All Jersey politicians, including backbenchers, may propose amendments to the Budget.

However, those seeking to make an amendment are required to provide full costings, financial implications and identify funding sources.

Jersey also provides private briefings with Treasury officials and offers a dedicated, non-governmental research team to support backbenchers in developing amendments.

Deputy Gardiner, who was first elected in 2019, said this support structure strengthens the role of scrutiny within the legislative process.

Tynwald’s Committee is examining whether similar reforms could be adopted on the Isle of Man following longstanding criticism from members and the public over the lack of early access to Budget information.

Currently, all other items for Tynwald consideration must be on the Register of Business at least four weeks before debate, yet the Budget is exempt from this rule.

The evidence forms part of the Committee’s efforts to develop reform recommendations.

A public call for written submissions - inviting views on the effectiveness of scrutiny mechanisms, timeframes, amendment powers and the role of scrutiny committees - closes today (30 May).

The next phase of the inquiry is expected to include evidence from the Isle of Man Government’s Chief Financial Officer and senior Treasury officials in October.